Learning Center
We keep you up to date on the latest tax changes and news in the industry.

Tax Considerations for Scam Losses

Dealing with the aftermath of scams, particularly the tax obligations associated with them, presents unique challenges. Recent legislative changes now restrict casualty and theft losses primarily to those linked with declared disasters. Nonetheless, those who have fallen prey to scams can still explore potential tax relief options.

Historically, tax law permitted deductions for theft losses not covered by insurance. Though recent amendments have tightened these allowances, focusing mostly on disaster-declared losses, opportunities remain. Specifically, deductions may apply if you were victimized during a transaction aimed at generating profit.

Section 165(c)(2) of the Internal Revenue Code provides a noteworthy exception for losses from transactions driven by profit motives. If your scam-related financial loss is linked to profit-seeking activities, deductions might be possible without needing a disaster declaration. Grasping this provision might offer valuable financial solace following fraudulent schemes.Image 3

Criteria for Profit-Motivated Loss Deductions: To qualify for this advantage, several key criteria must be satisfied:

  1. Profit Intention: The transaction must be primarily aimed at economic gain. The IRS requires tangible proof demonstrating genuine profit motive, often involving detailed documentation to substantiate such intentions.
  2. Transaction Type: Often, acceptable transactions include investments like securities, real estate, or income-generating activities. Social or personal motivations typically negate eligibility.
  3. Loss Provenance: Losses must be directly attributable to profit-driven transactions, supported by thorough financial records and legal proof. Scams targeting investments often fulfill this criterion if they meet the documented profit motivation.Image 2

Understanding IRS Guidelines: Correct application of this deduction demands consultation of IRS memoranda to clarify deductible scenarios. A recent IRS Chief Counsel Memorandum offers insights into when losses qualify:

Schedule a Complimentary Consultation
Choose from our locations and meet with one of our qualified staff members. If you prefer to secure a Virtual Meeting via Zoom or Phone, please contact our offices at 877.908.1040
Schedule Here

  • Investment Frauds: Even with fraud, deductions are possible if initial investments had a valid profit expectation. Documentation proving transaction authenticity and profit intent is essential.
  • Theft in Profit Contexts: These incidents are scrutinized, requiring monetary losses to arise from profit-motivated transactions, not casual social exchanges.

Negative Tax Outcomes: Losses from scams involving IRAs or tax-deferred funds bear significant tax consequences. Withdrawals under scam duress potentially raise taxable income and risk early withdrawal penalties.Image 1

For traditional IRA or deferred plan funds, ill-timed withdrawals due to scams are taxed as ordinary income, potentially pushing you into a higher tax bracket. Furthermore, if you're under 59½, a 10% early distribution penalty applies, adding to financial woes.

Roth IRAs offer some relief, given after-tax contributions allow penalty-free withdrawals if holding periods are satisfied. Yet, removing earnings early, for non-qualifying reasons, could still incur taxes.

Below are illustrative cases indicating whether scam or theft qualifies as loss deductible, emphasizing profit motive as critical:

  • In scams like impersonator frauds, if intent aligns with profit safeguarding, losses may qualify as deductible theft losses.
  • Conversely, scams devoid of profit intent, such as romance scams, generally don't qualify for deductions.
  • Kidnapping scams focused on coerced fund transfer usually lack the profit motive necessary for deductible claims.

These scenarios underlie the importance of proper documentation and motive clarity. IRS scrutiny on non-disaster loss claims necessitates precise compliance, distinguishing eligible from non-eligible claims. Consulting our firm when faced with dubious transaction solicitations is crucial. Educating and proactive engagement, especially with vulnerable family members, helps shield assets and fosters enduring financial security.

Schedule a Complimentary Consultation
Choose from our locations and meet with one of our qualified staff members. If you prefer to secure a Virtual Meeting via Zoom or Phone, please contact our offices at 877.908.1040
Schedule Here
Share this article...

Want tax & accounting tips and insights?

Sign up for our newsletter.

I confirm this is a service inquiry and not an advertising message or solicitation. By clicking “Submit”, I acknowledge and agree to the creation of an account and to the and .

TAX DRx at a Glance

Our expertise is widespread and we have multiple office locations to make it convenient for you to get help. You can find us at:

TAX DRx Corporate Headquarters

502 Centennial Ave
Cranford, NJ 07016
(Grd St Pkwy - Ext 136)
(877) 263-1041

NYC - MSG Office

5 Penn Plaza, 19th Fl.
New York, NY 10001
(8th Ave & 34th St.)
(Sbwy A, B, C, LIRR, etc.)
(877) 263-1041

TAX DRx - Hillside

*Charles Dort, Managing Partner*
1568 Maple Ave, Store #1
Hillside, NJ 07205
(Corner of Conklin Ave)
(877) 408-1048

TAX DRx, dba/ TaxJohn

TaxJohn Tax Services
121 Park Ave
Plainfield, NJ 07060