Learning Center
We keep you up to date on the latest tax changes and news in the industry.

Can Your Dog Be a Tax Dependent? An Unprecedented Lawsuit Explores the Possibility

If you've ever wondered if your loyal pet could be considered a tax dependent due to attending to their vet bills, grooming costs, and other related expenses, you're not alone. One persistent attorney is challenging the existing tax norms on this very matter.

In December 2025, New York attorney Amanda Reynolds filed a groundbreaking lawsuit against the IRS, insisting that her eight-year-old golden retriever, Finnegan, be recognized as a legal dependent for tax purposes.

Image 3

While the case might seem like a whimsical legal endeavor, it does spotlight a common taxpayer question: Are pet-related expenses deductible? Let's delve into the specifics of the case and what tax law really allows regarding tax benefits related to our beloved animals.

The Legal Claim: Canine Dependency

Reynolds’ legal claim is rooted in the belief that Finnegan satisfies the IRS’s criteria for dependents, citing that:

  • He lives with her full-time,
  • Lacks any income sources, and
  • Depends on her for over half of his support, with yearly expenses surpassing $5,000 on essentials like food and medical care.

According to a national news report, Reynolds argued that "Finnegan is like a daughter" and therefore a dependent.

Additionally, she presents constitutional arguments, emphasizing that tax regulations inaccurately discriminate between dependents based on "species," constituting an Equal Protection violation and an improper "taking" under the Fifth Amendment.

Current Status of the Case

Currently under scrutiny in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of New York, the case is in a holding pattern. Discovery processes are paused as the IRS prepares a movement to dismiss. A court's written order acknowledges the case’s critical question of whether pets should be considered dependents under tax laws. Yet, it indicates significant challenges ahead, stating the claim appears "unmeritorious on their face."

Image 1

IRS's Definition of a Dependent

Central to the case is the IRS's definition of a dependent as an “individual.” Under the Internal Revenue Code Section 152, dependents are "qualifying children" or "qualifying relatives," both terms historically human-centric.

Schedule a Complimentary Consultation
Choose from our locations and meet with one of our qualified staff members. If you prefer to secure a Virtual Meeting via Zoom or Phone, please contact our offices at 877.908.1040
Schedule Here

The tax framework doesn't support listing pets as dependents. Dependents require Social Security Numbers or taxpayer ID numbers, with credits and deductions focusing on human family relationships.

While Reynolds argues Finnegan fits the functional dependency criteria, the federal tax code is not structured to recognize animals as dependent “individuals.”

Existing Tax Benefits for Animals

While routine pet expenses generally aren't deductible, here are the scenarios where tax benefits exist:

1) Medical Deductions for Service Animals

Trained service animals aiding disabilities may incur medical expenses eligible for deduction if itemized and surpassing AGI thresholds. Related costs for training and maintenance linked to medical care might qualify. Note, however, emotional support animals typically don't count as federal service animals.

2) Business Deductibility for Working Animals

Some animals integrated into a business, like guard dogs for property protection or pest control animals, may have costs considered ordinary business expenses. Documentation and authentic business purpose are essential.

Image 2

3) Charitable Deductions for Foster Animals

Taxpayers fostering animals for recognized organizations might deduct specific unreimbursed expenses as contributions, adhering to strict rules and documentation.

Conclusion for Taxpayers

This lawsuit resonates emotionally, as pets constitute family for numerous Americans, with related costs undeniably high. Yet, tax law is driven by definitions, not emotions.

  • You can't claim a pet as a dependent on your federal taxes.
  • Routine pet expenses aren't typically deductible.
  • Specific animal-related costs might be deductible in rare cases, like those for service, business, or fostering-related purposes.

Ultimately, monitoring Reynolds' case is crucial, not for expecting a tax revolution, but as a reflection of how household dynamics and tax policies distinctly delineate between "family" and "property." Before assuming deductibility, always verify what falls under IRS recognition and what lies outside its allowances.

Schedule a Complimentary Consultation
Choose from our locations and meet with one of our qualified staff members. If you prefer to secure a Virtual Meeting via Zoom or Phone, please contact our offices at 877.908.1040
Schedule Here
Share this article...

Want tax & accounting tips and insights?

Sign up for our newsletter.

I confirm this is a service inquiry and not an advertising message or solicitation. By clicking “Submit”, I acknowledge and agree to the creation of an account and to the and .

TAX DRx at a Glance

Our expertise is widespread and we have multiple office locations to make it convenient for you to get help. You can find us at:

TAX DRx Corporate Headquarters

502 Centennial Ave
Cranford, NJ 07016
(Grd St Pkwy - Ext 136)
(877) 263-1041

NYC - MSG Office

5 Penn Plaza, 19th Fl.
New York, NY 10001
(8th Ave & 34th St.)
(Sbwy A, B, C, LIRR, etc.)
(877) 263-1041

TAX DRx - Hillside

*Charles Dort, Managing Partner*
1568 Maple Ave, Store #1
Hillside, NJ 07205
(Corner of Conklin Ave)
(877) 408-1048

TAX DRx, dba/ TaxJohn

TaxJohn Tax Services
121 Park Ave
Plainfield, NJ 07060